You voted Archie McPhee your favorite joint to get stuff you don't need, but think about this: Are you sure you don't need a Benjamin Franklin action figure, a potato gun, a handful of rubber bugs and a "Smoking Baby"? What home is complete without a Sushi Shower Curtain, a half-dozen Devil Duckies and a Bacon Air Freshener? Believe us, you need this stuff.
You also mentioned...
Roq La Rue, Paperhaus, Romanza and Midway Swap and Shop.